Trump threatens nuclear option for Huawei; China formally arrests Canadian hostages

Access Archive

1. Huawei and the Canadian hostages

In the last 24 hours, U.S.-China tensions ratcheted up once again, this time by several notches.  

On Wednesday, May 15, Donald Trump issued an executive order declaring a national emergency caused by foreign adversaries “increasingly creating and exploiting vulnerabilities in information and communications technology and services.” The order instructs the commerce secretary, Wilbur Ross, to ban transactions “posing an unacceptable risk.”

Although not singled out by name, Huawei was the target. The Commerce Department separately announced “that it had placed the company and its dozens of affiliates on a list of firms deemed a risk to national security,” per the New York Times (porous paywall).

  • Huawei is already effectively excluded from the U.S. market. If the threat implicit in the executive order goes through, Huawei will not be able to buy American-made components that are vital to its supply chain.

  • Qualcomm, Intel, and Broadcom are among Huawei’s American suppliers who stand to lose business.

  • Because so many global mobile network operators are dependent on Huawei equipment, the knock-on effects could be felt worldwide.

  • However, Huawei “has been preparing for almost a year” for this eventuality, says the South China Morning Post, by stockpiling American components.  

  • For more on why the latest American move could be so consequential for Huawei and China, see Bloomberg’s Huawei threat by Trump is nuclear option to halt China’s rise (porous paywall) or this Twitter thread by Bloomberg journalist Joe Weisenthal.

On Thursday, May 16, at the Chinese foreign ministry’s regular media briefing, the spokesperson announced that the two Canadians detained after the arrest of Huawei CFO Mèng Wǎnzhōu 孟晚舟 in apparent retaliation have been formally charged, reports the South China Morning Post.

  • Former diplomat and International Crisis Group associate Michael Kovrig was charged with gathering state secrets, while entrepreneur and North Korea specialist Michael Spavor was charged with stealing and providing secrets for overseas forces.

  • Kovrig and Spavor were originally detained in December 2018. The formal arrest “means the cases are still in the investigation phase but now the prosecutors are directly involved as well as the public security forces,” explains Maggie Lewis in this informative Twitter thread.

  • The Canadian government’s response was to release a statement: “Canada strongly condemns their arbitrary arrest as we condemned their arbitrary detention on December 10.”

Other Huawei news:

  • “News from the Netherlands: intelligence services investigating Huawei in relation to Chinese espionage activities, @volkskrant reports, citing ‘intelligence sources’ (without more details),” according to a tweet by journalist Laurens Cerulus.

  • “Never mind the 5G network,” says a tweet by British satirical and news magazine Private Eye. Unfortunately, you have to buy a print copy to read how “Huawei is already embedded in every British embassy throughout the world, carrying vital confidential information.”

  • How are other countries responding to Trump’s Huawei threat? The Guardian has a roundup.

—Jeremy Goldkorn

2. No date for next trade talks, as broader conflict looms

After Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said yesterday, “My expectation is we will most likely go to Beijing at some point in the near future to continue those discussions,” Beijing today declined to confirm further talks, according to the SCMP. Saying that China is “not aware of the United States’ trip plan,” a spokesperson at the Ministry of Commerce added:

Both sides had candid and constructive communications in the last round of talks, but very regretfully the US unilaterally and continuously escalated the trade conflict, which led to grave damage to the discussions.

  • Trade talks have indeed taken “grave damage,” though reporting continues to come out — recently from the SCMP and Nikkei — that confirms the Reuters account that what broke negotiations was Beijing playing hardball and deleting substantial portions of the draft trade agreement related to law enforcement of commitments.

Besides the Huawei hunt covered above, a few recent things indicate even more unsteady U.S.-China relations in the foreseeable future:

  • “Trade can no longer anchor America’s relationship with China,” according to a special report by David Rennie at The Economist (porous paywall). “America has become more confrontational because multinational businesses that oppose barriers to trade have lost clout in a populist age,” Rennie notes. On Twitter, Rennie adds that “America and China really could stumble into a new cold war.”

  • “Trump sees a China trade deal through a new prism: The 2020 election,” the New York Times reported (porous paywall) several days ago, noting how enthusiastically Trump has seized on the message that Joe Biden, the current democratic frontrunner for 2020, is weak on China.

  • “Tom Friedman and Steve Bannon agree on China. What else does the Chinese leadership need to know about the American sentiment towards China?,” NYT columnist Li Yuan tweeted. She was referencing an interview between the two where Bannon preaches his economic nationalist gospel — unchanged from the early days of the trade war — and the famous NYT columnist nods along, including as Bannon asserts this:

The elites [in Europe and the U.S.] thought the rise of China [was] like the second law of thermodynamics, it was some physical reality we just had to accept. Thucycides trap says we’re the declining power, they’re the rising power. What Donald Trump says [is] you’re got it wrong. We’re the dominant power, and we’re going to reform the world along the lines of free market, democratic capitalism.

Other recent reporting on U.S.-China trade and related issues:

—Lucas Niewenhuis

3. Swine fever to have ‘stunning’ impact on pork industry

An official from the China Animal Agriculture Association today told an industry forum that the African swine fever epizootic “represents a national crisis requiring more government funding to quell,” reports the South China Morning Post.

He said that the damage to the country’s US$128 billion pork industry is unknown, “and any estimate of the economic impact from the virus on the swine industry will be ‘stunning.’”

Not everyone sees this as bad news, though. Bloomberg notes (porous paywall) that “while China’s pig supplies tumble in the wake of the contagious swine epidemic, its imports of pork, beef, seafood, poultry and sheep meat from suppliers from Brazil to New Zealand are booming.”

—Jeremy Goldkorn


Our whole team really appreciates your support as Access members. Please chat with us on our Slack channel or contact me anytime at

—Jeremy Goldkorn, Editor-in-Chief



The rover’s landing site lies within a vast impact depression created by an asteroid strike billions of years ago.

Now, mission scientists have found evidence that impact was so powerful it punched through the Moon’s crust and into the layer below called the mantle.

Chang’e-4 has identified what appear to be mantle rocks on the surface.

It’s something the rover was sent to the far side to find out.

China leads the world in solar and wind capacity, but a significant amount of the potential generation goes unused due to a lack of coordinated planning with the power grid and provincial-level governments, which are often under pressure to support other local generators such as coal plants.

Yet the era of power wastage, which is known as curtailment, may be coming to an end. A notice (link in Chinese) from the National Energy Administration (NEA) and state planner the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) yesterday told local energy authorities to come up with a plan for maximizing the share of renewable electricity they consume, based on their current resources.


Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong [黃之鋒 Huáng Zhīfēng] returned to prison on Thursday after he sought to appeal a court case relating to the 2014 pro-democracy Umbrella Movement. However, the appeal judge shortened the sentence from three months to two. Wong was among several protesters who failed to comply with an injunction to clear the Umbrella Movement protest camp in Mong Kok.  


“At work, we emphasize the spirit of 996. In life, we should follow 669,” Ma [马云 Mǎ Yún] told 102 couples at an annual company mass wedding on May 10, referring to the “996” work week, where employees are expected to work from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. six days per week. The second number, “669,” refers to sex six times in six days — with an emphasis on duration (nine sounds like “long time” in Chinese).

Ma’s comments prompted a backlash after a video of his speech was posted to Alibaba’s official Weibo account. China Women’s News asked in a Weibo post if the Alibaba founder should be discussing employees’ private lives. Another Weibo user wrote, “Everyone is working 996, who is in the mood for 669?”

Ma’s comments were also clearly aimed at men and reinforced harmful ideas of male sexual dominance, Liu Xingyu, a member of the Suzhou-based non-governmental organization Queer Workers’ Service Center, wrote in an online essay.


Q&A: Amy Zhang on high-conviction investing and small cap equities

As the first Chinese female partner at the asset management firm Alger, Amy Zhang is known for her distinctive approach to investing. Unlike most peer investors in the field, Zhang describes herself as a “stock picker” whose goal is to build high-conviction and benchmark agnostic portfolios of what she believes are exceptional small companies that have the potential to become successful larger companies. Zhang’s unique strategy is highly rewarding. During her time at Alger, the Small Cap Focus Fund grew from less than $15 million to over $3.5 billion and has established a strong track record and significantly outperformed the stock market indices.

Q&A: Roseann Lake on China’s single women shaping the country’s economic future

Roseann Lake covers Cuba for The Economist and was previously based in China as a journalist for five years. During her time in the country, she became fascinated with the lives of the single women around her, whose stories she captured in the book “Leftover in China: The Women Shaping the World’s Next Superpower,” which was published in China this year. We spoke with her about her life as a China correspondent and how Chinese women are becoming an increasingly vital force in the nation’s economy.

Speakers spotlight for SupChina’s third annual Women’s Conference

SupChina’s third annual Women’s Conference is just around the corner. To give you a taste of what to expect, we have published a series of interviews with the speakers, who told us some amazing stories about their careers and their thoughts on a range of topics.


Sinica Podcast: ‘Haunted by Chaos: China’s Grand Strategy,’ with Sulmaan Wasif Khan

This week on Sinica, Kaiser and Jeremy speak with Sulmaan Wasif Khan, assistant professor of international history and Chinese foreign relations at the Fletcher School at Tufts University, about his book, Haunted by Chaos: China’s Grand Strategy from Mao Zedong to Xi Jinping. He makes the case that China’s overriding concern is for maintaining the security and integrity of the state — something that, given China’s long history of foreign invasion, warlordism, civil war, and contested borders, hasn’t been easy.