Russian and American warships nearly collide in the East China Sea

Access Archive

Dear Access member,

On June 19, we’ll be hosting another SupChina Direct conference call. Our guest this time: Stephen Roach, former head of Morgan Stanley Asia and currently a professor at Yale University.

It’s free for all Access members — please click here to sign up.

Also: Happy Dragon Boat Festival!

—Jeremy Goldkorn, Editor-in-Chief

1. Russia vs. United States in the East China Sea  

Friday, June 7 — This morning, CNN broadcast a video of a Russian warship almost colliding with an American warship, and reported that both sides were blaming the other. This comes just a few days after a similar dispute between the two countries about plane intercepts over the Mediterranean.


  • A U.S. Navy spokesperson said: “A Russian destroyer…made an unsafe maneuver against USS Chancellorsville, closing to 50-100 feet, putting the safety of her crew and ship at risk.”

  • The near-collision happened earlier today, as Xí Jìnpíng 习近平 was wrapping up a three-day state visit to Russia. Xi earlier called Putin his “best friend” while Putin said that Russian-Chinese relations had reached “an unprecedented level.” Xinhua has published a couple of Xi-Putin bromance photos.

  • The Russian Navy blamed the American vessel for the incident, accusing “the US Navy of ‘unacceptable’ and dangerous maneuvering,” according to Russian state-owned blog RT.

  • Former U.S. Navy officer and New York Times reporter Mike Forsythe does not buy the Russian story, commenting on Twitter:

It’s pretty obvious who was doing the provoking in this shot. The Russian ship was closing the distance between the two ships. At [the] beginning of the clip was on starboard quarter of the US ship, at the end was athwartships and much closer.


If we assume, as I do after watching the video, that the Russian action was intentional, this explanation offered by retired U.S. Navy rear admiral John Kirby to CNN makes the most sense:

“Clearly this sends a strong message to President Xi, from Putin’s perspective, that we are on your team.”


While Russia may not be admitting to acting on China’s behalf with the actions of its navy, Russian President Vladimir Putin was quite explicit on Friday, June 7, in slamming U.S. moves against Huawei. Reuters reports that he condemned “the situation around the company Huawei that they are attempting not just to squeeze but to unceremoniously push out of the global market.”

Russia is doing its part to ensure Huawei does have a role in the global market. On Wednesday, June 5, Huawei “signed a deal…with telecoms company MTS to develop a 5G network in Russia over the next year,” according to Agence France-Presse.

2. China’s central banker is as cool as a cucumber

In an interview with Bloomberg (porous paywall), People’s Bank of China Governor Yì Gāng 易纲 said that China has “tremendous” room to adjust monetary policy to mitigate effects of the trade war:

“We have plenty of room in interest rates, we have plenty of room in required reserve ratio rate, and also for the fiscal, monetary policy toolkit, I think the room for adjustment is tremendous,” he said. Yi said the currency has been weaker recently due to “tremendous pressure” from the U.S. side but the impact will be temporary.

“A little bit of flexibility of renminbi is good for the Chinese economy and for the global economy because it provides an automatic stabilizer for the economy,” he said. “The central bank of China is pretty much not intervening in the foreign-exchange market for a long time, and I hope that this situation will continue, not intervening.”

3. The largest grave relocation in human history

Here is yet another record set by China: As the country has urbanized in the last 20 years, more than 10 million corpses have been exhumed in the largest grave relocation in human history.

Stanford historian Thomas S. Mullaney explains in this Q&A:

I found that the driving force behind these grave relocations has been the rapid development of third- and fourth-tier Chinese cities — cities that, unlike major metropolises like Beijing and Shanghai, few people outside of China have heard of. This development entails new highways, railways, airports, hospitals and primary schools, among other things. But the relocations are also centrally important to the income of local governments across China, who make money from leasing their land. Because there is no private land ownership in China, a central part of local governments’ budgets is money they make on renting their land.

For more on this fascinating subject, see the website Mullaney has created, Grave Reform in Modern China, comprising a series of essays on matters sepulchral, together with an interactive map of grave relocations.

4. And then, to nobody’s surprise, they came for the finance bloggers

In the Financial Times, Christian Shepherd reports (paywall):

Censors at two of China’s largest social media companies appear to have taken aim at independent financial bloggers, as Beijing continues pumping out propaganda to garner public support for its trade dispute with the US.

At least 10 popular financial analysis blogs on social media app WeChat had all present and past content scrubbed, according to screenshots posted by readers. The Weibo accounts of two non-financial popular bloggers, including Wang Zhian, a former state broadcast commentator who wrote about social issues, were also blocked.

This latest act of censorship, whatever the cause, should surprise no one. Also published today is this profile of former investigative journalist Liú Wànyǒng 刘万永 in the New York Times by Jane Perlez (porous paywall). Excerpt:

…Mr. Liu earned the nickname “Tibetan Mastiff” for his perseverance at the China Youth Daily, a paper run by the Communist Party but with a reputation for sometimes bending the rules.

More than a decade later, Mr. Liu, 48, has quit journalism. More than just a personal decision, however, his departure from the newspaper where he worked for 21 years represents the end of investigative journalism in China, a profession left in tatters by the pressure of Communist Party orthodoxy under President Xi Jinping.

5. German warship in the Taiwan Strait?

According to Politico, “high-ranking” German officials “are contemplating sending a warship through the Taiwan Strait — joining the United States and France in challenging Beijing’s claims to what the West regards as an international waterway.”

Why? Bloomberg says (porous paywall) that “a naval mission to the region would be a low-risk way for Germany to show that it’s committed to alliances — and that it still has a navy.”

6. Faceprint is required for security purposes

Stephen McDonell of the BBC’s Beijing bureau was locked out of his WeChat account after he posted photos of June 4 demonstrations in Hong Kong. The app told him he was suspected of  “spreading malicious rumors,” but there was a way for him to reinstate his account. He just had to submit to a biometric scan:

Then came a stage I was not prepared for. “Faceprint is required for security purposes,” it said.

I was instructed to hold my phone up -— to “face front camera straight on” — looking directly at the image of a human head. Then told to “Read numbers aloud in Mandarin Chinese.”

My voice was captured by the App at the same time it scanned my face.

Afterwards a big green tick: “Approved.”

You can read the whole thing here: China social media: WeChat and the Surveillance State.


Our whole team really appreciates your support as Access members. Please chat with us on our Slack channel or contact me anytime at

—Jeremy Goldkorn, Editor-in-Chief

Here are the stories that caught our eye this week:

  • The 30th anniversary of June Fourth was marked by a large number of reports, commentaries, and remembrances of the bloody crackdown. SupChina’s Anthony Tao published a list of 30 essential stories to read about June 4, 1989. The Chinese embassy in Washington responded to Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s criticism of Beijing on the anniversary with a statement asserting, “China’s human rights are in the best period ever.”

  • China blamed the U.S. for trade talk breakdowns in a white paper published by the State Council Information Office, and the U.S. Trade Representative accused China of having chosen to “pursue a blame game misrepresenting the nature and history of trade negotiations.” Chinese government departments then issued three warnings to Chinese citizens traveling to the U.S. in two days:

    • The Ministry of Education said that Chinese students in the U.S. are facing restrictions and difficulties with visas that are affecting their ability to complete their studies.

    • The Ministry of Culture and Tourism warned all Chinese citizens about “American shooting incidents, robberies, and incidents of theft.”

    • The Ministry of Foreign Affairs warned of “many kinds of harassment” by U.S. authorities.

    Meanwhile, Trump threatened to expand tariffs to include another $300 billion in Chinese imports, but said he would wait to make a decision until after the G20 meeting in Osaka, June 28–29.

  • China’s threat to cut the U.S. off from rare earths is getting real, as indicated by a June 4 meeting of the powerful National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC), which focused on rare earth supplies. In response, the U.S. Commerce Department vowed “unprecedented action to ensure that the United States will not be cut off from these vital materials.”

  • Building a domestic 5G network is now an urgent national priority for China, one to be achieved by any means necessary, and possibly at great cost. The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology announced this week that it has approved licenses for the commercial rollout of fifth-generation telecom technology to major state-owned mobile carriers. Meanwhile, China’s 5G leader, Huawei, reportedly has as many as 10,000 of its employees, some of them working nonstop for days, assigned to reducing the company’s reliance on American technology.

  • Chinese Defense Minister Wèi Fènghé 魏凤和 made an uncompromising speech in Singapore on June 2, at the annual Shangri-La Dialogue. He said that China has no intention to be “the boss of this world,” but defended Beijing’s absolute right to do whatever it pleases in territory it controls or lays claims to — from Xinjiang to Taiwan to the South China Sea.

  • Two Arabic-language videos about Xinjiang went viral on YouTube recently, giving exposure to a crisis that, in many parts of the Arabic-speaking world, has been ignored or censored.

  • The U.S. Secretary of Transportation, Elaine L. Chao (趙小蘭 Zhào Xiǎolán), was the subject of a massive New York Times investigation into her family’s shipping business and connections in China. The Times found that the State Department had raised ethics questions about Chao’s family connections, that her father’s business has benefited from hundreds of millions in state-backed loans in China, and that her husband, Republican congressional leader Mitch McConnell, has benefited enormously from political and personal financial contributions from the Chao family.

  • An ecommerce site is being taken to court for counterfeit goods. One blogger has spent nearly a year amassing evidence that a bottle of cleansing oil sold by NetEase Kaola (网易考拉 wǎngyì kǎolā) was a fake, and not an import from Japan as claimed. It is not the first time that NetEase Kaola has been accused of selling fakes.

  • China successfully tested a floating sea launch platform for rockets for space missions. The project is a collaboration between the China Academy of Launch Vehicle Technology (CALT) and the Hong Kong–listed Great Wall Motors.


Aldi has become the latest overseas supermarket operator to open stores in China but the German company faces a battle to win over customers in a fragmented market in which foreign operators have traditionally struggled.

Hundreds of people lined in Shanghai on Friday to enter one of the two Aldi outlets opening in the city.

China’s demand for liquefied natural gas was in no danger of dwindling over the next decade as it moves toward a decarbonated future, but is, in fact, “almost infinite.” Li went on to point out that China will actually need more liquefied natural gas, not less, in order to complete its transition away from coal, saying, “In China, we have a coal-to-gas switching campaign going on, which contributed to huge demand growth, as well as imports of LNG.”



  • Taiwan elections — Han Kuo-yu
    Candidate seeks closer China ties, shaking up Taiwan’s presidential race / NYT (porous paywall)
    Chris Horton profiles Han Kuo-yu (韓國瑜 Hán Guóyú), populist presidential candidate “who wants friendlier ties with China — a sharp contrast to the incumbent, Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文 Cài Yīngwén), who rejects China’s claim that Taiwan is part of its territory.”

  • Chinese warships in Australia
    China warships leave Sydney after surprise visit ‘raises hackles’ / Reuters
    “Three Chinese warships sailed out of Sydney on Friday (June 7) after an unannounced visit that came amid a tussle for influence between Australia and China in the Pacific,” a visit that was planned by the government but not announced, causing some concern by the public.
    Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison defended the visit: “It was a reciprocal visit because Australian naval vessels visited China… So it may have been a surprise to others, but it certainly wasn’t a surprise to the government.”

  • U.S. response to Uyghur internment camps
    U.S. Speaker Pelosi says Uyghur crackdown bill ‘moving in a positive direction’ / Radio Free Asia
    “House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi said this week that she supported legislation that seeks accountability for China’s harsh crackdown on Muslim Uyghurs that has landed some 1.5 million residents of the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region (XUAR) in internment camps.”

  • Hong Kong extradition law
    Outrage in Hong Kong as extradition plan exposes deep fears of China’s rule / NYT (porous paywall)
    Austin Ramzy and Katherine Li write:

Politicians have staged sit-ins and exchanged blows in the legislature. Lawyers, high-school teachers and even anime fans have organized petitions. And the authorities are bracing for protests Sunday that could be the largest since the pro-democracy Umbrella Movement shut down parts of Hong Kong five years ago.

Anger is boiling in Hong Kong over a push for a law that would allow people to be extradited to mainland China, legislation that critics say would subject residents of this semiautonomous territory to the security forces and courts controlled by the ruling Communist Party on the mainland.


Zhèng Chǔrán 郑楚然 began to run when she had run out of options to save her husband from the police.

Over the past month she has covered almost 90 miles, running in circles around the city where she lives in southern China. She tracks her progress via Weibo and Twitter every day and plans to keep running until she’s completed 6,200 miles (or 10,000 km), which is the distance between where her husband was arrested in China and the Old Trafford stadium in England, where his favorite soccer team, Manchester United, plays.


From rare earths threat to 5G: Top news this week

From China’s threat to cut the U.S. off from rare earths to the approval of a commercial rollout of a 5G network, here are some top news items we covered this week.


‘The New King of Comedy’: A remake that shouldn’t have been made

The 1999 film King of Comedy 喜剧之王 is one of director Stephen Chow’s most beloved movies, a silly, offbeat comedy with plenty of heart. The 2018 remake The New King of Comedy follows the same basic formula, but with some notable differences. There are jokes and feel-good moments and family values, but nothing that makes it more special than your run-of-the-mill New Year movie.

‘We are Filipinos, and we hate China’: China’s influence in the Philippines, and backlash against Tsinoys

The Philippines, under President Rodrigo Duterte, has opened its arms to China, which has alarmed Filipinos, who are fearful that China will trample their country’s sovereignty in the disputed South China Sea and handicap the archipelago with burdensome “debt trap” Belt and Road projects. Recent anger directed toward China has inflicted what experts call “collateral damage” upon the Tsinoys, i.e., Filipino Chinese, who historically have persisted through discrimination.

Tiananmen Square 30 years later: 30 essential stories about June 4, 1989

On the 30th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown, SupChina’s Anthony Tao compiles 30 essential stories to read about June Fourth. The list includes firsthand and contemporary accounts of the protests and bloodshed, analysis of Communist Party documents illuminating what led to the decision to use deadly force, and poetry and multimedia resources and essays that make the monumental events of 1989 feel personal to this day.

A memorial to Uyghur civil rights and the legacy of Tiananmen

In 1989, the Uyghur student activist Örkesh, better known in English-language media as Wu’er Kaixi, was one of the leaders of China’s nascent — and short-lived — pro-democracy movement in Tiananmen Square. Twenty years later, after mass protests (and riots) in Xinjiang were forcefully put down, Uyghurs who showed any sign of civil disobedience would be categorized in one of three ways: as separatists, extremists, or terrorists. The space for Uyghurs to petition for civil rights — for another Wu’er Kaixi to step up — had disappeared.

Porn, AI, and slut shaming: A Chinese programmer’s war on ‘promiscuous’ women

On May 27, Weibo user @将记忆深埋, a Germany-based Chinese entrepreneur, announced the completion of an AI-powered algorithm that uses facial recognition technology to identify porn actresses and cross-reference their appearance in adult content with their online presence on social media.

Kuora: How many Chinese know about the ‘June Fourth Incident’? More than you think

Official accounts of what happened on June 4, 1989, at Tiananmen are by no means censored in China: These talk about a student-led uprising that was, in the official version, hijacked by “black hands” among intellectuals who were working at the behest of foreign governments for the overthrow of the Chinese Communist Party. There are certainly many people in Beijing and around China who care very deeply about what happened 30 years ago, who want the whole episode talked about openly and honestly. And there are, alas, many more who see nothing good coming out of such a reckoning.

Q&A: Ingrid Yin on China’s healthcare industry and new medical technologies

Ingrid Yin is the co-founder and portfolio manager of MayTech Global Investments, a New York–based firm that specializes in managing global growth portfolios. At the 2018 SupChina Women’s Conference, she was chosen as the U.S. recipient of the Female Rising Stars Award. In this interview, Yin talks about how she started the company and what she makes of the growing investment opportunities in China’s healthcare sector.

Friday Song: ’99 Bends in the Yellow River’ and an elegy for Chinese civilization

“Do you know how many bends are on the Yellow River?” belts the singer, in Shaanxi dialect, to begin the folk tune “99 Bends in the Yellow River” (天下黄河九十九道湾). Listening, it’s easy to imagine he’s reaching deep into both heart and history to find those notes, washed up on the shores of the Yellow River itself. But there’s another story, one complicated by politics, involving the 1989 student protests at Tiananmen Square.


Click Here

ChinaEconTalk: From Beijing to Cairo: Peter Hessler and the craft of foreign correspondence

This week on ChinaEconTalk, Jordan speaks with veteran journalist Peter Hessler. Peter spent seven years in China as a correspondent for The New Yorker, followed by five years in Egypt. In this episode, Peter discusses his long and prolific career reporting on the society, politics, and culture of these two dynamic nations; he also considers the similarities and differences in the ways the Chinese and Egyptian people make sense of their respective places in the world based on their rich historical and cultural legacies. In addition, Peter reflects on the 30th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre, and contrasts it with the 2013 mass protests and eventual coup d’état in Cairo.

TechBuzz China, episode 46: Futu, Tiger, and the trillion-dollar overseas online brokerage business from China

In episode 46 of TechBuzz China, co-hosts Ying-Ying Lu and Rui Ma take a look at the market for China’s overseas online brokerages, which help Chinese people to invest in securities outside of mainland China. Of note, two Chinese fintech startups, Futu (富途 fù tú, or “path to riches”) and Tiger Brokers, went IPO in quick succession in March. This episode tells the stories of Futu and Tiger against a backdrop of relative volatility for U.S.-listed Chinese equities, as compared with their NASDAQ and NYSE peers.

Sinica Podcast: China’s New Red Guards: Jude Blanchette on China’s far left

This week, Kaiser sits down with Jude Blanchette in the Sinica South Studio in Durham, North Carolina, to talk about Jude’s new book, China’s New Red Guards: The Return of Radicalism and the Rebirth of Mao Zedong, which just came out on June 3. Jude explains the origins of the neo-Maoists and others on the left opposition, and how overlooking the conservative reaction to reform and opening impoverishes our understanding of China and its politics.

The Caixin-Sinica Business Brief, episode 88

This week on the Caixin-Sinica Business Brief: recent updates on the trade war, cheaper Tesla cars for the Chinese market, China’s rapidly growing short-video industry, Doug Young on a Hong Kong restaurant that’s in the news, and more.

Middle Earth, episode 12: Dealing with cultural differences in the workplace

The stark cultural differences between China and the West are frequently identified as key barriers in productive professional exchanges. However, the mechanisms by which people can actually improve their cultural understanding — or “cultural literacy” — are less clear. How can professionals in China and the West bridge gaps in understanding to ensure that business can sail smoothly?

Subscribe to Middle Earth on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, or Stitcher, or plug the RSS feed into your favorite podcast app.