A tipping point in Hong Kong?

Access Archive

Dear Access member,

Our word of the day is tipping point: 引爆点 yǐnbào diǎn — literally, “point of detonation.”

SupChina is hiring a business reporter! Please spread the news

Tune in to the CHINA Town Hall next Monday, November 18, at 6 p.m. EST. We will be simulcasting the event from our Facebook page for the National Committee on U.S.-China Relations. 

—Jeremy Goldkorn, Editor-in-Chief

A screenshot from a video of an intense standoff between protesters and police at the Chinese University of Hong Kong on November 12. 

1. A tipping point in Hong Kong?

“The Hong Kong government has taken the unprecedented step of warning 180,000 employees they will face immediate suspension and other disciplinary action if they are caught taking part in unlawful public activities,” says the South China Morning Post

Other news and views from and of Hong Kong: 

“[I]t’s felt like we’re at some type of tipping point since Wednesday. What’s happening right now is simply unsustainable,” writes the anonymous Hong Kong–based scholar behind the Being Water newsletter:

Either the government acknowledges everything they’ve tried has failed and they set a new course or things are about to get a lot worse. For the third time in the past five months, it seems like this would be the time PLA or PAP intervenes if that’s a card Beijing is willing to play. I don’t see how they could get inside these Fortress Universities without using live ammo if they don’t want to wait out the students barricaded inside.

Things are so unpredictable that the universities might be abandoned as soon as I hit ‘send.’ Only a fool would make predictions.

“The 11-year-old dissident: Hong Kong’s schoolchildren fuel protests” is the title of a Wall Street Journal article (paywall): “Extreme youthfulness of protesters has alarmed Chinese officials [as] a new type of front line emerges in high schools.”

“Beijing has demanded that the British government investigates an incident in which Hong Kong’s justice minister fell over and hurt her arm during a confrontation with protesters in London,” reports the South China Morning Post.

2. Mood music, but still no phase one deal 

The Wall Street Journal reports (paywall): 

The U.S. and China are nearing a trade deal, but President Trump isn’t ready to sign off, White House economic adviser Lawrence Kudlow said Thursday.

They are getting close to an agreement, Mr. Kudlow said in an event held at the Council on Foreign Relations.

“The mood music is pretty good,” he said, adding that Mr. Trump “likes what he sees, he’s not ready to make a commitment, he hasn’t signed off on a commitment for phase one, we have no agreement just yet for phase one.”

Other news from various fronts of the U.S.-China techno-trade war, day 498:

Huawei: No Google, no problem? “Chinese tech giant Huawei is selling its first folding smartphone without Google apps or U.S.-made processor chips following sanctions imposed by Washington,” reports the Associated Press. “The long-awaited Mate X foldable phone sold out within seconds of being made available in China on Friday, months after the planned mid-year launch,” says TechNode.

“China has agreed to lift a more than four-year-old ban on U.S. poultry imports, both governments said, in what a U.S. industry group said could lead to sales of about $2 billion of poultry,” according to the Wall Street Journal (paywall):

American poultry had been banned in China since 2015 following an outbreak of avian influenza, and the two sides have discussed lifting the ban as part of the trade negotiations between Beijing and Washington.

—Jeremy Goldkorn

Here are the stories that caught our eye this week:

  • University campuses became battlegrounds in Hong Kong, as police broke a previous unwritten rule treating them as safe havens. The Chinese University of Hong Kong and other colleges canceled classes for the rest of the semester, as protesters engaged in clashes with police that looked like medieval sieges. 

  • A second protester was shot by police with live bullets, on Monday, November 11, the same day that a man was lit on fire following an argument with demonstrators. 

  • Xí Jìnpíng 习近平 commented publicly on the protests, saying, “Stopping violence, controlling chaos, and restoring order are Hong Kong’s most urgent duties.” State media featured these comments more prominently than any previous coverage of Hong Kong, and a deluge of propaganda articles followed calling for more arrests and stricter punishments for protesters. 

  • The U.S. and China have still reached no agreement on rolling back tariffs, or on how much China would purchase in U.S. agricultural products and when. Meanwhile, two reports came out this week with dramatically different takes on U.S.-China relations: John L. Graham and Benjamin Leffel wrote, “The data of the last 25 years portray U.S.-China commerce as the most synergistic bi-lateral relationship in world history, bringing peace along with mutual prosperity.” Meanwhile, the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission released a nearly 600-page report that raised alarm about a multitude of aspects of the U.S. relationship with China, and generally advised Washington to get substantially tougher on Beijing. Chinese companies are paying no heed to any of this, as they continue to prioritize New York over Hong Kong for their future IPOs. 

  • Women initiate over 70 percent of divorces in China, Zhōu Qiáng 周强, president of the Supreme People’s Court, revealed. This contrasts with long-held assumptions that Chinese women tend to endure unhappy marriages due to societal expectations and economic pressures. 

  • Xi Jinping visited Greece, where officials made friendly noises about the start of a “new era,” and agreed on new Chinese energy investments in Greece. Xi also offered to help Greece retrieve the contested Parthenon Marbles from the U.K., where they are kept at the British Museum, despite decades of Greek complaints. 

  • Xi then went to Brazil, where he schmoozed with President Jair Bolsonaro, who gladly returned the favor despite his fiery rhetoric about China on the campaign trail last year. Brazil was rewarded with a billion-dollar investment in the port of Sao Luis via China Communications Construction Company. 

  • Chinese company sentiment may be deteriorating, according to a post by well-connected lawyer Dan Harris on his China Law Blog. Companies that his firm helps advise are increasingly exhibiting short-term thinking similar to Russian companies in the 1990s. 

  • Alibaba recorded $38.4 billion in sales during its genius annual publicity stunt, Singles Day, while rival JD.com reported $29 billion from bandwagoning on the same concept. 


Two former executives of a Chinese unit of Herbalife Nutrition were criminally charged in the United States on Thursday over an alleged decade-long scheme to bribe Chinese government officials and circumvent the company’s internal accounting controls, a person familiar with the matter said… Both defendants are 51-year-old Chinese citizens and remain at large. 

Mainland China’s total lottery sales for September stood at 36.4 billion yuan ($5.19 billion), down 13 percent year-on-year, according to official data published on Thursday by the country’s Ministry of Finance. Sales of lottery products have now declined for eighth straight months, according to official data.

China’s JD.com Inc beat analysts’ estimates for quarterly revenue on Friday, boosted by stronger sales in its core ecommerce business, sending its shares up nearly 7 percent. The company attributed the strong results to growth in lower-tier cities…

The company’s total net revenue rose 28.7% to 134.8 billion yuan ($19.27 billion) in the third quarter ended Sept. 30. Analysts had expected revenue of 128.6 billion yuan.


The U.S. Food and Drug Administration on Thursday approved BeiGene Ltd’s lymphoma treatment, validating the China-based drugmaker’s strategy of largely using data from trials held outside the United States to file for approval…

The FDA granted accelerated approval to the capsules for treatment of adult patients with mantle cell lymphoma, who have received at least one prior therapy. 

Mantle cell lymphoma is a rare, aggressive form of non-Hodgkin lymphoma, a blood cancer that most often affects men aged over 60. The company estimates between 3,000 and 4,000 new patients were diagnosed in the U.S. in 2015.


Sweden’s minister for culture will be banned from entering China if she attends a literary award ceremony on Friday for detained Swedish bookseller Guì Mǐnhǎi 桂敏海, Beijing’s ambassador to the Nordic country said on Friday.

Gui Minhai, a Chinese-born Swedish citizen, was abducted in Thailand in 2015 and is now detained in China. When based in Hong Kong, he published books critical of China’s leaders, and the case has soured ties between Sweden and China.

Svenska PEN, a literary organization, has awarded Gui Minhai the 2019 Tucholsky Prize, praising his work in the service of free speech. An empty chair will symbolically represent the writer at the ceremony in Stockholm on Friday, Svenska PEN said. As is customary, the award is to be presented by Swedish Culture Minister Amanda Lind.

“If Amanda Lind, in spite of our advice, attends this ceremony, then no government representatives responsible for cultural affairs will be welcome to China,” Chinese Ambassador Guì Cóngyǒu 桂从友ui told Swedish news agency TT.

…Sweden’s foreign ministry said its view remained that China should release Gui Minhai and that it had contacted Chinese authorities over the ambassador’s statements.

“It is not okay to interfere with what the Swedish government does,” Foreign Minister Ann Linde said in an emailed statement to Reuters.

Internet regulators in Shanghai have shut down Chinese news website Business Times after it refused to comply with an official order to change its name and cease “unauthorized” reporting activities.

The bilingual outlet’s parent company, whose name translates to Shanghai Leading News Information Technology, used the “Business Times” name to “illegally conduct interviews, publish, and reprint online news and information,” thereby disrupting the distribution of news on the internet and misleading the public, according to a Wednesday announcement [in Chinese] by the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC).

A family of strongmen are eyeing a return to power in Sri Lanka’s presidential election on Saturday, an outcome that could also shift the island nation back toward China.

The Rajapaksas, once a powerful force in the island nation’s politics who lost the presidency in 2015, are staging a comeback. This time Gotabaya Rajapaksa, 70, is running for the top job, backed by family members including his brother Mahinda, who enjoyed warm ties with Beijing during his 10-year rule.

Tokyo confirmed last month that a Japanese man in his 40s had been held by Chinese authorities since September on suspicion of violating Chinese laws, without providing details…

“We confirmed his return…I’m glad he is back to Japan safely,” Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi told reporters without disclosing the details of the charges. “This is a case that Prime Minister [Shinzo] Abe and I strongly pressed on China and this has borne fruit.”

In Beijing, China’s foreign ministry said the man — who they identified as Nobu Iwatani — confessed to collecting a large amount of “classified information”.

“The facts are clear, the evidence is conclusive,” said spokesman Gěng Shuǎng 耿爽 at a regular press briefing in Beijing.

The man is suspected of violating both China’s criminal and counter-espionage laws and is awaiting trial on bail, Geng told reporters, adding that the man left China on Friday and returned to his home country…



  • How the U.S. should deal with China
    U.S. doesn’t need to break up with China / Bloomberg (porous paywall)
    Scott Kennedy and Jude Blanchette write: “The Trump administration’s policies are drawing the two nations toward a self-destructive decoupling. There’s a better way.”

  • Western disillusionment with China
    The West is now surer that China is not about to liberalize / The Economist
    Columnist Chaguan attended the Stockholm China Forum, “a semi-annual meeting for politicians, officials, ambassadors, business bosses, scholars and journalists hosted by Sweden’s foreign ministry and the German Marshall Fund, a think-tank,” where the mood was gloomy:

Long ago at these gatherings Western speakers urged China, too, to be smart. They would craft clever ways to explain why liberal economic and even political reforms would be in China’s own interests. Not this time. A reform-minded Chinese speaker said his country was “too big, too old and too conservative” to adopt a different model. Some of the Westerners dared to suggest that autocratic statism might harm China in the long term. Chinese counterparts scolded them for “cultural arrogance”. Talking is better than fighting, but it can still feel pretty bleak.


Click Here

Andrew Yang warns ‘new Cold War’ with China is bad for U.S.

“We’re not going to be able to address global threats like climate change and even collaborate on artificial intelligence if we don’t have a certain level of cooperation between the U.S. and China,” presidential candidate Andrew Yang told SupChina before a fundraising event in New York City on November 10. “Right now, unfortunately, our relationship is trending in the wrong direction…toward a new Cold War.”


Click Here

How do you build a digital presence in China as a foreign business? Find out the answer at the NEXT China conference.

For international brands, establishing a presence in or breaking into the China market in the digital era can be both exciting and risky. Wonder why? Jimmy Robinson, co-founder and director of PingPong Digital, will be at SupChina’s NEXT China conference to answer your questions.

Will the U.S.-China trade dispute (perversely) open new opportunities for cross-border investment? Find out at the NEXT China conference.

Chinese deals approved by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) seem to clear at a rate of 50–60 percent under the Trump administration, whereas the percentage was over 95 percent when Obama was in office. Interested in learning more about how to navigate CFIUS’s review process and what new opportunities might arise in the landscape of cross-border investment? Global law firm King & Wood Mallesons will be at our NEXT China conference to answer your questions.

Death threats for opponent of internet addiction center in China

It’s been two years since Yuzhang Academy (豫章书院 Yùzhāngshūyuàn), a Confucian institute that purportedly treats internet addiction in Nanchang, Jiangxi Province, closed its doors after a high-profile scandal over its use of torture methods on students. But earlier this month, the facility came under the public eye again after a Weibo user claimed he has received death threats from people associated with the school because of his commitment to helping former attendees seek legal justice against their abusers.

Bare branches: A brief history of China’s wildest consumer holiday

“Singles Day” in China began as an ad hoc attempt at self-mockery. It is now the world’s largest shopping day

The man who unified China and commissioned the Terracotta Warriors

The founding emperor of the Qin dynasty (ruled 221 B.C.E. to 210 B.C.E.), Yíng Zhèng 嬴政, known to history as Qín Shǐ Huáng 秦始皇, is best known as the man who unified China after the long chaos of the Warring States period, often through brutal means advocated by the Legalist school of thought.

Friday Song: ‘Forgive me for loving freedom’: The enduring Hong Kong rock anthem

For 25 years, the 1993 ballad “Boundless Oceans, Vast Skies” from the Hong Kong band BEYOND has soared above protests, marches, and rallies in mainland China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. 


Click Here

Sinica Podcast: Fuchsia Dunlop on ‘The Food of Sichuan’

Kaiser and guest host Jim Millward interview Fuchsia Dunlop, the preeminent writer on Chinese cuisine in the English language. She has recently published a completely revised and updated version of Land of Plenty, her classic book on Sichuan cookery, containing 70 new recipes.

NüVoices: Sino-Black relations with Keisha Brown

In this episode, Keisha Brown explains the history of Sino-Black relations, tells the story of influential African-American individuals like W. E. B. Du Bois and Langston Hughes and their ties to China, and the changing perceptions of race and identity in China.

Strangers in China, Chapter 5: Far from home, part 1

This episode explores what it’s like growing up on China’s economic periphery, removed from the ever-growing metropolitan areas along the coast, as well as some familiar stresses of growing up, how these experiences shape who we become, and the unfamiliarity of living in a new place.

The Caixin-Sinica Business Brief, episode 103

This week, on episode 103 of the Caixin-Sinica Business Brief: Beijing’s former vice mayor pleads guilty to taking $19 million in bribes, Alibaba inches toward a second IPO in Hong Kong, and an update on the tepid and tentative trade agreement being hashed out between Beijing and Washington.

ChinaEconTalk: Reinterpreting Beijing and its history

Jeremiah Jenne, history teacher, writer, and the man behind Beijing by Foot, is in the guest seat this week. He speaks with Jordan about the changes — both tangible and intangible — that Beijing has undergone in the last few decades.