U.S. dials up criticism of China over Xinjiang amid more evidence of cultural and reproductive repression

Foreign Affairs

A U.S. State Department official described China’s Xinjiang region as “an open-air prison” and reiterated the Department’s view that Beijing is committing genocide against Uyghurs. Meanwhile, several more reports have detailed how the Chinese government is chipping away at Muslim culture and life in Xinjiang.

A part of a minaret broken off from the former Xinqu Mosque lies in a yard next to the former house of worship in Changji outside Urumqi, Xinjiang, May 6, 2021. REUTERS/Thomas Peter

Yesterday, the U.S. State Department released its annual report on international religious freedom, this time covering the year 2020. Senior Official Daniel Nadel gave a press briefing on the report in which he:

  • Reiterated the Department’s view, unchanged since a last-minute declaration by the Trump administration, that China is committing “ongoing crimes against humanity and genocide” against Uyghurs and other ethnic minorities in the Xinjiang region.
  • Said that China is engaged in “an attempt to erase a people, a history, a culture from the Earth, and that’s unacceptable.”
  • Characterized Xinjiang as “an open-air prison” where movements are closely tracked and Uyghurs have “minders who have been assigned to live” with them.

More evidence of cultural and reproductive repression in Xinjiang

In recent days, several more reports have detailed how the Chinese government is chipping away at Muslim culture and life in Xinjiang:

Increased pressure from U.S. and other countries

Nadel, the State Department official, said that in advance of the Beijing 2022 Olympics, the U.S. was working with allies and “reviewing options on policy and messaging,” including “countering Beijing’s intent to use the games as a platform to somehow validate their governing model and paper over their gross human rights violations.”

  • 152 participants from 51 countries attended a UN event on Xinjiang co-sponsored yesterday by 15 Western countries. One notable country in attendance was Turkey, home to the largest Uyghur refugee population, which gave a statement expressing concern over “extreme human rights violations.” Context on SupChina last year: Criticism of China’s Xinjiang policies grows at UN.
  • A trade blacklist for Xinjiang solar panels? Climate envoy John Kerry said that due to concerns over forced labor, the Biden administration “was assessing whether to add [solar panels and some of their components, including rare earth minerals,] to the list of products from Xinjiang Province that the United States is already penalizing,” per AP.
  • Pressure on G7 to act on forced labor: President Biden is expected to tell allies that “values need to be infused in our trading relationships,” an advisor told Reuters, when he travels to Britain in June.

China’s response

In today’s Foreign Ministry press briefing, spokesperson Huà Chūnyíng 华春莹 deplored (in English, Chinese) the UN event as “awash with outrageous lies and disinformation” and a “despicable shoddy show and sheer political farces.” She then stated, “I must point out that these countries that are always trying to lecture others on human rights issues actually have a deplorable record on human rights and have committed piles of crimes,” and continued with whataboutery for several minutes. Context on SupChina: China and Russia condemn sanctions, accuse West of ‘politicizing human rights issues.’

Separately, religious leaders from five mosques in Xinjiang “spoke at the 90-minute presentation, three in person and two by video. They all described prayers and feasting for Eid al-Fitr and rejected criticism of China’s religious policies,” per AP.